Dr Peter Alegi, Department of History, Michigan State University
Albert Luthuli’s place in the history of South African liberation
movements derives primarily from his two crowning achievements:
President of the African National Congress (1952-1967) and the
first African to be honored by the Nobel Committee (1960 Peace
Prize). Interestingly, however, Luthuli was a latecomer to activist
politics, joining the ANC at age 50. This paper begins to probe
an earlier period in Luthuli’s life, when the teacher and
organizer (and later elected Zulu chief) engaged the world of sport
through his involvement in football (soccer). He revealed his passion
for football in his autobiography:
“I became a compulsive
football fan,” while teaching at Adams College in Durban
in the 1920s. “To this day,” he noted, “I am
carried away helplessly by the excitement of a soccer match” By
exploring aspects of Luthuli’s sporting career, this study
attempts to show the ways in which his role in sport administration
boosted the development of black football in South Africa.
In some ways, Luthuli’s contribution exemplifies the heritage
of struggle in black sport before the 1950s. It laid the foundation
from which the anti-apartheid sport movement built its campaign
to isolate white South Africa from international sport in the 1960s
and 1970s. After a brief description of the Luthuli family’s
background, this paper turns to an examination of Luthuli’s
involvement with the Adams College Shooting Stars Football Club.
The focus then shifts to his service on the executive of the Durban
and District African Football Association and his key role in the
founding of the South Africa African Football Association and the
Natal Inter-Race Soccer Board. If successful, this paper will deepen
our understanding of the changes and continuities in the relationship
between sport and the liberation struggle in South Africa.
Mvumbi (“continuous rain” in Zulu) Albert John Luthuli
was born near Bulawayo in the Matabeleland region of Southern Rhodesia
(Zimbabwe), around 1898. He was the son of John and Mtonya Luthuli,
two Zulu Christians (amakholwa). His mother’s roots were
in the Qwabe clan, but she had grown up in Zulu royal circles.
As a young woman she left these privileged circumstances and converted
to Christianity. His father had fought with colonial forces in
the Matabele (or Ndebele) rebellion in Southern Rhodesia and stayed
on after the hostilities ended. The senior Luthuli then worked
as an evangelist and interpreter in a Seventh Day Adventist mission,
at which point Mtonya and their son Alfred rejoined the family
after journeying all the way from their home in Groutville, located
in the Umvoti Mission Reserve in Natal. The death of the patriarch
a few months after the birth of Mvumbi motivated the Luthuli family’s
return to South Africa in 1908 or 1909. Mtonya entrusted Mvumbi
to his uncle Martin Luthuli, the elected Zulu chief of Groutville.
There the young Luthuli was enrolled in a mission school.
Western education and Christianity granted Luthuli membership in
the privileged class of Natal kholwa – a tiny group of Africans
that played an influential role in the early history of black South
African sport. In 1914 Luthuli studied at the Ohlange Institute
near Durban. Modeled after Booker T Washington’s Tuskegee
Institute in the United States of America, this vocational school
was established in 1901 by John L Dube, a kholwa educated in the
USA and the first president of the South African Native National
Congress in 1912 Luthuli left Ohlange in 1915 for the Edendale
Methodist school outside Pietermaritzburg. At Edendale he embarked
on a teachers’ training course, which engendered a in him
passion for teaching. It is unclear the extent of Luthuli’s
participation in sporting activities as a student, but it is possible,
given his later interests, that he occasionally played football
and tennis.
Upon completion of his training course in 1918, he
accepted the post of principal and only teacher at a primary school
in rural Blaauwbosch, Natal. Here Luthuli was confirmed in the
Methodist Church and became a lay preacher. As has been noted elsewhere, “The
language of the Bible and Christian principles profoundly affected
his political style and beliefs for the rest of his life.” In
1920, Luthuli accepted a government scholarship for a secondary
school teacher training course at Adams College in Durban. “I
left Blaauwbosch, little imagining that I would be spending the
next fifteen years of my life at Adams” Luthuli said.
Adams College, known as Amanzimtoti Training Institute before 1914,
was founded in 1849 by Congregationalist missionaries of the American
Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions, based in Boston, Massachusetts.
By the time Luthuli arrived in 1920, Adams had become one the best
schools in southern and central Africa. Having qualified as a high
school teacher, Luthuli declined the offer of a scholarship to
attend the University College of Fort Hare. Instead, he stayed
on to teach Zulu and music (and other subjects) in the teacher
training school at Adams, hoping that the £10 monthly salary
would help provide for his aging mother.
“Adams was a world of its own,” Luthuli noted, one “in
which we were too busy with our profession to pay more than passing
attention to what happened elsewhere.” But, as one scholar
has pointed out, while “the students at Adams led a uniquely
sheltered and insular life … their conditions were far from
idyllic.” Teachers’ wages were low and sporting facilities
inadequate. Despite enjoying kholwa status, some students struggled
to make ends meet. For instance, Anton Muziwakhe Lembede, founder
and first president of the ANC Youth League in 1944, wore shabby
clothing. Luthuli showed empathy with working people’s concerns:
he joined the Natal Native Teachers Union and in 1928 was elected
its secretary. He accrued valuable political experience by organizing
boycotts and acting as a negotiator with white authorities.
At Adams, sport provided an important meeting ground for Western
and indigenous cultures. Football was the school’s most popular
sport. As a young faculty member, Luthuli took the helm of the
Adams College Shooting Stars Football Club in the 1920s. Aside
from his job as supervisor and secretary of the club, his participation
in athletic activities seems to have been limited: “Beyond
playing an occasional game of tennis for exercise, I took no part
in sport while at Adams,” Luthuli later recalled. Shooting
Stars was among the oldest and most prestigious African sides in
Durban, having started playing matches against outside opponents
as far back as the 1890s. In addition to the Shooting Stars, American
Board missions had produced many of the earliest African clubs
in Durban, such as Ocean Swallows of Umbumbulu (established in
the 1880s), Natal Cannons of Inanda (1890s), and Bush Bucks of
Ifafa (1902).
Institutional support for soccer at Adams reflected the American
missionaries’ endorsement of “muscular Christianity,” the
ideology at the heart of the rational recreation movement in Victorian
England and the United States. Luthuli fully embraced the muscular
Christian value of “healthy mind in a healthy body” which
underpinned the endorsement of sport at Adams. “All work
and no play makes Jack a dull boy,” Luthuli opined; “in
the case of people whose occupation involves much mental strain
play is needed in order to give rest to their minds.” In
his twenties, Luthuli internalized the liberal view that sport
was a useful tool to “moralize leisure time” of African
youths. “Games develop and call for the exercise of those
qualities which contribute to the highest manhood,” Luthuli
believed, “and for most of us they help to keep us occupied
in our leisure moments when otherwise the devil would be finding
work for our idle hands.” One way to measure Luthuli’s
success in this endeavour is to highlight that many former Adams
students went on to become players and officials in football leagues
and clubs in Natal and Transvaal.
African football’s founders on the Rand, for instance, were
mission-educated, Zulu-speaking clerks. In 1917 the mabalans, as
these white-collar employees were known, established the Witwatersrand
and District Native Football Association. The leadership of the
mine league was structured along ethnic lines. Dressed in western-style
clothing, these secretarial workers occupied a key position between
management and miners, leading “mine companies to develop
recreational activities for them which not only occupied their
leisure time and emphasized their elite status but also promoted
an ethos of loyalty to the mine.” As early as 13 October
1923, the Chamber of Mines newspaper Umteteli wa Bantu reported
that “all kinds of sports are organized and in various other
ways provision is made to keep the Natives wholesomely amused.”
Adams alumni were part of this contingent of privileged clerks
that held sway over black leisure on the Rand. Sport suited this
male elite, engaged in a hesitant struggle to be heard and seen
in a hierarchical segregationist society. The mabalans, like Luthuli
himself, expressed a “profound cultural ambivalence” about
their identity, which straddled traditionalist and modern experiences
as well as the lower echelons of white supremacist society and
upper reaches of the black oppressed. Many clerks embraced aspects
of colonial culture that gave voice to their aspiration – to
be set apart from the mass of ordinary workers. Clearly then, Luthuli,
and Africans in general, were not simply duped into adopting Western
sport: Africans enjoyed the game for their own reasons and on their
own terms. Football was an attractive aspect of Western culture
that Africans appropriated and deployed in different ways and often
for different purposes than those originally intended by forces
of colonialism and capitalism.
In a political economy defined by Africans’ poverty and landlessness,
Adams occupied a privileged position. Control of its sporting facilities
meant that the school did not depend on the largesse of Durban’s
white municipal authorities for access to playing fields. This
degree of independence from white control allowed students to train
more assiduously, a key to the Shooting Stars success. Partial
autonomy enabled Adams to host weekend matches that boosted the
prestige and influence of students, teachers, and the institution
in the social and cultural life of the port city.
As will be shown
below, Luthuli and the other teachers and staff from Adams and
neighboring mission schools used this limited freedom wisely, as
they steered the association clear of white power whenever feasible.
One must not overstate the power and privilege of Adams. For example,
playing conditions were far from ideal. Luthuli lamented the shortage
of playing fields at Adams, where one football field and one tennis
court served about 200 student-athletes. The formation of a second
and then third team in the early 1930s intensified the pressure
for more playing space and exposed the school’s inability
to meet increasing demand. Still, Luthuli and Adams worked tirelessly
to address this challenge. Judging by the performance of Shooting
Stars during Luthuli’s tenure, these efforts met with remarkable
success.
In the first issue of the Adams College magazine Iso Lomuzi (Eyes
of Our Village), Luthuli wrote a short history of Shooting Stars.
Between 1908 and 1913 the team performed well, reaching the semi-finals
and finals, but the Durban championship proved elusive. For unknown
reasons, the Adams club did not join the Durban and District Native
Football Association (DDNFA) when it was officially founded in
1916. Upon affiliation with the DDNFA in 1921, Shooting Stars won
the Marshall Campbell Cup, thereby earning a share of the city
title. (The club that won the most trophies in a season was crowned
champion.) Luthuli credited a supportive (white) teacher named
Louis Elliot for leading the side to victory – an unusual
case of interracial cooperation on (or off) the playing fields.
After some lackluster years, the club won the city title outright
in 1925 and 1926 under the captaincy of Mark “uMqafi” (Zulu
for heavy drinker, delinquent) Radebe and Kenneth Kwela respectively.
For various reasons, several clubs were suspended from DDNFA in
1927 and the Shooting Stars, still under Kwela’s guidance,
triumphed in the only competition completed. The following year
brought renewed success to Adams football. Led by captain Frank “Dangerous” Nkonkhobe,
Shooting Stars won three cups to remain Durban champions. They
lost their title to Rebellions in 1929, despite winning two trophies
with Christopher Phera as captain, but reclaimed it in 1930, winning
three of five competitions: the Bushbucks Challenge Cup, the Inter-District
Cup, and Durban and District Cup.
Luthuli seems to have developed a sound technical knowledge of
football through his lengthy involvement with Shooting Stars. The
skilful Adams method of play, for example, impressed the president
of the (white) Durban and District Football Association during
a personal visit to the school. As a result, this sympathetic white
official suggested the possibility of bringing the professional
Scottish club Motherwell to Adams in 1934 for a coaching clinic
during the Durban leg of the side’s South African tour. Recognizing
this opportunity to expose the young student-athletes to the tactical
and stylistic approaches of British professionals, Luthuli accepted
the offer. Unfortunately, heavy rain moved the event indoors to
the dining hall. Despite the inclement weather, there was palpable
excitement in the air as Luthuli “presided over a large gathering
of students and teachers.” Highlights of the scaled-down
event included the Motherwell captain, R. Ferrier, giving useful
coaching advice to the students and the latter offering “hearty
cheers” as the guests were introduced individually.
(The
loudest applause, Luthuli carefully noted, went to the three Scottish
internationals: MacFayden, Stevenson, and McClory.) The climactic
conclusion to this long and “memorable gathering” saw
the students belting out the school song and “Nkosi Sikelel’ iAfrika.” The
Motherwell trainer and players followed this performance with a
rousing rendition of “Hail, Caledonia”! Whether Motherwell’s
visit improved the quality of soccer at Adams is unclear. But it
is probably safe to speculate that it generated renewed enthusiasm
and interest in the game. Soon after the Motherwell visit the younger
players challenged the senior side more effectively. According
to a member of the Young Tigers, Adams’ second, team: “The
Shooting Stars lost some of the lustrous reputation to the younger
team, whose ‘movement with the ball [made] the opponents
stand and stare at them’.” This evidence is consistent
with the argument that Motherwell’s short-passing style,
tactical defense, and dazzling victories against all-white South
African teams had a momentous impact on the local game beyond the
confines of Adams; simply put, the Scots radically changed how
black South Africans played their football.
Luthuli’s engagement in sport at Adams College convinced
him that football was a new cultural idiom with special value for
political mobilization. As a form of popular culture that cut across
class, regional, and generational lines, it could help to build
political alliances between Durban’s mostly Zulu urban workers,
rural migrants, and mission-educated elites. The populist appeal
of football stoked Luthuli’s interest in the game: “what
has attracted me as much as the game,” he recalled, “has
been the opportunity to meet all sorts of people, from the loftiest
to the most disreputable.
” Not everyone at Adams supported
this agenda. Rev Gideon Sivetye, a member of Shooting Stars and
a teacher at Adams since the 1890s, remembered having to endure
criticism for bringing elite student-athletes into regular contact
with illiterate domestic servants, dockworkers, ricksha-pullers
and other lower-class African players and fans. “As teachers
we were criticized for going to Durban to play with the wild boys
who were working in Durban,” Sivetye said. “We had
to answer questions of ministers, etc. I am glad to say our principals
joined us; they thought it was a way of attracting them, to co-operate
with us… It did a lot of good, this playing with those people
in town. We got to know each other” Alert to the power of
sport and popular culture, white missionaries and school administrators
capitalized on Africans’ passion for football by using the
game to recruit students. As Sivetye remarked: “We got a
lot of students to come to the school. Ohlange especially advertised
themselves that way.”
During Luthuli’s tenure at Adams in the 1920s and early
1930s football in Durban ceased to be a pastime for the kholwa
elite and integrated itself into the everyday life of Durban’s
mostly Zulu-speaking African population. The popularization of
African soccer unfolded in the context of enormous social transformations
caused by increasing urbanization, industrial expansion, and intensifying
racial segregationism. The massive growth of cities such as Durban
was evident in the rise of South Africa’s official urban
population from 1,478,000 in 1911 to 4,300,000 in 1946. Urban migration
in South Africa had a distinctly male character. In Durban, for
example, the ratio of African men to women was 6.6: 1 in 1921 and
3.4: 1 in 1936. As a result, most players and fans were single
men, migrant (or recently immigrated) workers performing menial
jobs.
Unlike the kholwa elite, working-class Zulu men had little
or no formal education, spoke Zulu, and belonged to African independent
churches, and/or practiced indigenous religions. Working-class
Africans’ low wages and long work hours made weekend trips
across greater Durban to play and watch football both time-consuming
and expensive. Many players undertook long journeys on foot or
bicycle from their homes to the grounds, often arriving late for
kickoff and sapped of energy. With access to only three grounds
in Durban until the mid-1930s, African footballers displayed determination
and commitment in order to run a long soccer season from April
to November, and, occasionally, into December. Weekend matches
regularly attracted about 5,000 spectators, but big rivalries,
semi-finals and finals drew crowds twice that size.
Albert Luthuli’s involvement in football broadened beyond
Adams College in the late 1920s. Thanks to his experience with
Shooting Stars and his growing reputation as a skilful negotiator
with the Natal Native Teachers Union, he was elected vice-president
of the DDNFA in 1929. By that time, the number of clubs affiliated
to the DDNFA had risen from seven in 1916 to about two dozen. Luthuli’s
arrival proved timely. African football in 1929 in Durban was experiencing
rough times, largely as a result of the city’s sudden explosion
into the political “storm center of South Africa.” The
peak of popular African resistance in 1929-30 was a boycott of
Durban’s municipal beerhalls – the main source of revenue
for Native Administration. Government repression turned Durban
into a combat zone, leaving two white members of the security forces
and four black workers dead. Football too was disrupted and the
association turned to Luthuli to help rebuild its organization.
Luthuli’s managerial skills, together with his charisma,
boosted football administration in the port city. During his first
year in the executive the association released its first official “Annual
Report” The improved organization of African football in
Durban, partly thanks to Luthuli’s efforts, elicited commendation
in 1930 by a white official of the Chamber of Mines’ Native
(Labor) Recruiting Corporation: “The Natives manage their
own soccer affairs and they do it well. [They are] very proud of
this privilege and they resent any interference as far as soccer
is concerned.” On a personal level, Luthuli found the debates
and conflict-resolution typical of sport administration rewarding: “I
love the impact of mind upon mind, and I love thrashing things
out in the attempt to get at the truth. The procedures of the court
give these things orderliness, and getting at the truth is worthwhile
for its own sake.” Football afforded Luthuli an opportunity
to engage an audience more representative of the broader urban
population than that comprised of the small, relatively homogenous
audience of African teachers and students.
African football, however, posed new challenges. In Durban in the
early 1930s, for instance, Luthuli and his colleagues in football
had grown more concerned about white encroachment into black leisure.
Much of the resentment stemmed from the municipality’s social
amelioration program launched after the riots of 1929-30. The limited
annual funds made available for African sport and recreation ((between £1000
and £1500) provided much-needed benefits but threatened the
relatively high degree of autonomy of the DDNFA. DDNFA was especially
worried when the newly appointed Native Welfare Officer, whose
salary consumed half of the funds earmarked for black sport, began
to intervene in an authoritarian manner in local football. In an
attempt to defend African sport’s independence, representatives
of the DDNFA met with (white) councilors on the Native Affairs
Committee and members of the Native Affairs Department in November
1930. The African delegation selected Luthuli as its spokesperson.
The most important issue discussed was whether the Native Welfare
Officer, J Rawlins, had the authority to require that the association
request his permission to charge admission at games. Luthuli and
his colleagues politely, but firmly, criticized Rawlins’ position.
In the course of vigorous discussion, it became known that the
association charged only for marquee matches and that the average
gate takings were between £9 and £10. These funds were
used for maintenance of the grounds and meeting traveling expenses
of DDNFA teams playing in inter-town contests in Ladysmith and
Pietermaritzburg. The Africans defended their right to charge admission
by pointing out how the municipality had funded, in years past,
the erection of a barbed wire fence around most of the main ground
in central Durban.
“ The Council had expressed the view that
the Natives should do something to assist themselves and it was
by means of these admission charges,” said DDNFA president
THD Ngcobo, “that [Africans] were able to support and maintain
the grounds without having to approach the Council for assistance
on every occasion.” By highlighting the municipality’s
earlier endorsement of the association’s economic self-help
approach, Luthuli’s delegation worked the system to its advantage,
thereby moderating the pernicious effect of white intrusion. HE
Arbuckle, the chairman of the Native Affairs Committee, eager to
prevent an escalation of tension in Durban’s volatile political
climate, ordered that any future conflicts over sport between Africans
and whites needed to be solved not by the Native Welfare Officer’s
unilateral decisions but through consultation.
This meeting underscores how Luthuli’s political thinking
reflected a commitment to securing the small victories that could
be won through increasingly assertive, but polite, protests against
paternalist white rule. He was a man of his times. Looking back
on his days as a young teacher, Luthuli recalled how “the
world seemed to be opening out for Africans. It seemed mainly a
matter of proving our ability and worth as citizens, and that did
not seem impossible... [though] we were, of course, aware of the
existence of colour prejudice”.
A leading exponent of this
liberal-democratic perspective was Professor DDT Jabavu, president
of the All Africa Convention, an umbrella African political movement
formed in 1935. Jabavu encouraged politically active Africans “to
evolve an intermediary policy of using what can be used and fighting
against all that we do not want.” Luthuli favored conservative
constitutional tactics, clinging to the hope of African political
assimilation. But as the white government hardened its segregationist
policies, African sport found itself increasingly on the defensive.
For example, in Durban in 1931 the municipal authorities tightened
control over black sport by establishing a Bantu Recreational Grounds
Association, which pocketed fifteen percent of the association’s
ticket income.
In this shifting political context, Luthuli supported a move to
change the name of the Durban & District Native Football Association
in 1932 to Durban & District African Football Association.
The deeper intrusion of Durban’s white authorities into black
sport, in part, accounted for Luthuli’s pan-ethnic appeals
to mobilize a more radical movement to combat colonialism. The
shift also exemplified a rising African political consciousness
that could be traced back at least to 1923, when the SA Native
National Congress adopted the title of African National Congress.
Radical and progressive Africans also increasingly used the term “African” in
the 1920s and 1930s.
The involvement of Luthuli and trade unionist
AR Ntuli in sanctioning the DDAFA name change suggests how football
was both cause and consequence of the heightened race-consciousness
and political mobilization of the inter-war period. Similar title
changes occurred around the country. In Johannesburg, African mine
clerks previously involved with the Johannesburg Bantu Football
Association and the moribund Witwatersrand & District Native
Football Association founded the Transvaal African Football Association
in 1930. The Cape Peninsula Bantu Football Association, formed
in 1927 in Cape Town’s Langa township, transformed itself
into the Western Province African Football Association in the mid-1930s.
Above all, the new titles highlighted how developments in football
were tied to changes in politics and society, where “race-conscious
populism provided the African elite with a viable ideological approach
to the problem of class division in the black community.”
A compromise on the issue of language demonstrates how Luthuli
tried to build solidarity across occupational, class, regional,
and ethnic lines. As a result of a constitutional amendment passed
in 1932, the Durban association made English the official language
so that delegates wishing to address meetings in Zulu needed the
chairman’s permission. This policy followed the indigenous
elite’s tradition of using English rather than African languages
in public life, a nod to Pan-Africanist argument that “if
Zulu were to be used other nationalities would suffer.” English
was also a marker of “respectability” and differentiation
from lower-class men with minimal or no formal Western education.
While DDAFA officials tended to take advantage of their English
fluency to cling to administrative positions at the expense of
the Zulu working class, Luthuli demonstrated sensitivity to issues
of language, culture, and class. An example of his cultural pride
and awareness was the Zulu Language and Cultural Society he formed
within the Natal Native Teachers’ Union “to revitalize
the Zulu language and culture.” “A polished orator
in English and in Zulu,” he was known to stand up for DDAFA
colleagues who spoke halting English before white officials. At
a meeting with Durban municipal authorities, “Luthuli intimated
that they desired to make their points as clear as possible, although
it was difficult for them in speaking in a foreign language.” Luthuli’s
willingness to embrace his Zulu identity further endeared him to
ordinary workers, players, and fans. His endorsement of isiZulu
also captured the contradictions dividing the kholwa, torn between
promoting a progressive, urbanized, and modern world-view and reveling
in pre-colonial glories.
Despite the challenges posed by white power and poverty, African
football expanded and a need arose for new competitions and a national
association. In 1930, top officials in Durban contacted the Transvaal
African Football Association (TAFA) with the purpose of establishing
a South African association and a national championship for Africans.
The DDAFA executive approached AF Baumann of the Durban firm Bakers
Ltd to donate a trophy for a national inter-provincial tournament.
Luthuli, representing the Natal African Football Association (of
which he was secretary-treasurer), and DDAFA president T Ngcobo
spearheaded the Durban contingent that, in cooperation with the
Transvaal, founded the South Africa African Football Association
(SAAFA) in 1932. He was named secretary and treasurer of SAAFA.
The national association forged an alternative definition of nationhood
and citizenship in direct opposition to the segregationist vision
constructed by white minority rule.
Luthuli’s and Natal’s powerful position in South African
soccer’s boardroom extended to the playing fields. Natal
hosted and won the inaugural Bakers Cup in Durban in 1932 and then
traveled to Johannesburg’s Bantu Sports Club to defend its
national title in 1933. The inter-provincial matches were regularly
staged on holidays when white businesses closed and black workers
enjoyed some leisure time. The 1933 championship took place on
a bank holiday, thus ensuring a large crowd and teams at full-strength.
In an electric atmosphere at Bantu Sports, some 4,500 paying spectators
(and many non-paying fans) roared as the teams appeared. Luthuli
led the Natal side onto the partially-grassed pitch, while a “band
of miners with their lanterns, [accompanied] the Transvaal team
onto the field as mascots.” The home crowd enjoyed “excellent
and thrilling soccer,” but most left disappointed after Richard “Wireless” Khumalo,
a star forward from the Ladysmith Rainbows, scored the winning
goal late in the game to give Natal a 2-1 victory and a second
consecutive title.
Due to the spiraling number personal and professional commitments,
Luthuli declined the presidency of DDAFA in early 1932. Between
May and August 1932, the association suffered a major breakdown.
The president, treasurer, secretary, and vice-secretary were all
charged with mismanagement and suspended. Luthuli was then asked
to serve with four others on a special Commission of Inquiry appointed “to
report on the various complaints, laid by certain clubs, against
your association.” He agreed. The Commission held twelve
meetings between 17 December 1932 and 22 February 1933. Citing
copious and persuasive evidence, its final report blasted the accused
officials for exercising arbitrary power, biased decision-making,
financial mismanagement, disregarding correspondence, keeping unintelligible
and partial minutes, and failing to train and protect referees.
The Commission recommended, among other things, that a financial
audit be undertaken on a regular basis to ensure greater accountability
and transparency. It also called for a full-time paid secretary
to improve the day-to-day running of the association—a change
enacted the following year. The Commission’s concluding comments
echoed Luthuli’s feelings; the Report stated that officials
should only accept positions “provided that they have the
time to devote to their duties... [They] should remember that they
have been chosen, to these positions, for the faith and trust that
their fellowmen have placed in them.” For the next two years
Luthuli worked tirelessly to heal factional divides within the
association, stressing the need for “brotherly love and no
individual recriminations.” In 1933 the job of financial
auditor was added to Luthuli’s expanding set of duties a
tribute to his indefatigable work ethic and impeccable integrity.
Overall, Luthuli played a crucial role in the DDAFA’s development
into a large, efficient, popular black-run organization. The Durban
association expanded steadily during Luthuli’s tenure on
the executive committee (1929-1935). The number of clubs increased
from twenty-four in 1930 to twenty-six clubs in 1931, thirty-one
in 1932, and then forty-seven in 1935. Registered players increased
from 900 in 1930 to about 1,500 in 1935. Luthuli and the DDAFA
executive worked with the municipality to obtain funding for the
construction of a fully enclosed Native Recreation Ground at Somtseu
Road location, which was completed in 1935-36. The new facilities
at Somtseu produced better football, attracted larger crowds, and
improved the financial prospects of the African game. The black
popular press noted how “soccer is the most powerful [sport
in Durban]… Football is a magnet… The [people are]
so interested in this game that the other sister games are simply
dwarfed.” The Bantu World summed up the local status of the
sport with a column entitled: “Bantu Sportsmen in Natal Know
Only One Game—Soccer.”
Football ceased to be an important part of Luthuli’s life
after he left Durban in January 1936 to assume the position of
elected chief in his home village of Groutville. Luthuli noted
how “leaving Adams wrenched me from this addiction.” It
should be remembered, however, that his commitment to the Groutville
farming community and, later, the anti-apartheid struggle, did
not completely sever his connections to the vicissitudes of South
African football. Luthuli made one final major contribution to
the development of the domestic game. In 1946 he joined forces
with Rev. Bernard Sigamoney, an Indian Anglican pastor (from Johannesburg)
and enthusiastic sport organizer in the finest “muscular
Christian” tradition, to establish the Natal Inter-Race Soccer
Board. Aimed at overcoming the racial balkanization of the game,
this body organized competitions between African, Indian, and Coloured
teams in the province. The Natal and Transvaal (est. 1935) Inter-Race
Boards represented an initial, perhaps necessary, step towards
the formation in 1951 of the anti-apartheid South African Soccer
Federation. In other words, Luthuli was at the forefront of the
process of transforming sport into a potent force for racial integration,
equality, and human rights. In the 1950s, as the ANC turned from
elite protest to civil disobedience and mass action during Luthuli’s
tenure as president of the organization, the white government imposed
bans on him. But Luthuli continued to be loosely linked to football
by holding ceremonial posts. His name, for instance, appeared under
the official title of “patron” on the official letterhead
of the DDAFA, SAAFA, and the South African Soccer Federation.
As the game transformed itself into a leading form of black popular
leisure in the first half of the 20th century, Albert Luthuli raised
the standard of African sport administration, fought to preserve
the partial autonomy of black football’s institutions, and
then fostered racially integrated sport. His experience with club
football (Shooting Stars), and with local (DDAFA), regional (Natal),
and national (SAAFA) associations heightened his awareness of ordinary
workers’ concerns and their expectations for adequate leisure,
health, and entertainment. Football management provided him with
crucial organizational training and experience before his entrance
into liberation politics and ascendancy to the leadership of the
ANC in December 1952. The populist nature of football may have
also enhanced Luthuli’s image as a trustworthy “man-of-the-people.” This
analysis of Luthuli’s sporting life allows us to make at
least two conclusions. First, counter-hegemonic sporting activities
often occurred at the local level and before the rise of apartheid.
Second, a historical analysis of the relationship between sport
and movements for political liberation is important because it
reveals how “serious fun” shaped and sustained a subaltern
and oppositional leisure culture.
“Over twenty-five years,” Luthuli recalled, “I have
played what part I could in organizing African and inter-racial
sport.” But the impact of his sporting career was greater
than this humble leader would care to admit. A quarter of a century
before Dennis Brutus launched the first anti-apartheid sport organization
(CCIRS, 1955), and nearly half a century prior to South Africa’s
expulsion from the Olympics (1970), Luthuli recognized the power
of sport to build solidarity through sociability and to serve as
a mobilizing force in the South African liberation struggle.